An investigation uncovers a web of influence in the powerful coalition aligned behind the European Commission’s proposal to scan for child sexual abuse material online, a proposal leading experts say puts rights at risk and will introduce new vulnerabilities by undermining encryption.
    • ExtremeDullard@lemmy.sdf.org
      221·
      1 year ago

      If the system was transparent, open, and provided an easy way to get false positive sorted, I wouldn’t necessarily even have a problem with the concept.

      How can you even say that?

      This is what baffles me the most: how does anyone even entertain the idea of letting a third-party scan their own files on their own device uninvited? Even if the process is transparent and there's a 100% fool-proof way of taking care of false positives, the very idea of letting anyone scan anything on my computers in the first place is completely unacceptable!

      People would have never deeemed anything like this even remotely acceptable 25 years ago. But in 2023, enough people have internalized the idea enough that this actually has a chance to become law without creating an outrage. I am utterly distressed by what society is willing to accept nowadays.

        • ExtremeDullard@lemmy.sdf.org
          6·
          1 year ago

          Your entire line of thinking hinges on the premise that the politicos (and presumably, whichever oligopolies their do the biddings of) will have their way one way or the other. What you're saying is, if we don't make concessions on the client-side scanning and accept some implementation of it, the privacy-respecting tools we have now will be banned.

          My question is this: why is any of this inevitable?

          None of what's being proposed here solves any problem. Pedo material can be fought with the legal and technical tools we have now, as demonstrated by the news of entire pedo rings being dismantled, and pedophiles going to jail as a result on a regular basis.

          The fact that you're willing to make compromises on solutions to a fake problem means that you've already acknowledged we've already lost.

          The truth is, if people today were as outraged as people of my generation are over this, this false choice wouldn't have to be made at all. Things are just fine the way they are today, and you don't have to give up anything if you don't assume you'll have to give something up.