• nifty@lemmy.world
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    1
    arrow-down
    9
    ·
    edit-2
    21 hours ago

    None of those words are the insults you think they are, but I think I should say something because I am sick of people being cowed by asshole assumptions behind words like these. I think many people are too firmly in ideological camps to understand what makes sense in different situations, and what may look like one thing may not necessarily be it. Regardless,

    Anti-immigration doesn’t mean you don’t want any immigrants or immigrants of a certain type only. Second, if you’re anti-illegal immigration doesn’t mean you’re anti-immigration. Third, all countries are free to set their immigration policies, why does anyone believe they have the right to be anywhere? I am not even anti-immigration, btw. That’s besides the point if I am making a devils advocate comment.

    There’s no such thing as imperialism in the modern world. The fact that some countries insist on blaming their shortcomings on imperialism is a distraction tactic so their citizens don’t turn on their failing or corrupt governments. I feel bad for the people of those countries.

    I simply hate that someone takes a historically failure idea like Marxism and creates a narrative around it which sets that ideology as morally or ethically superior. It’s just part of the narrative to make western country citizens hate their own countries so that they dismantle their democracies. Which is the sum total of what we’re seeing everywhere now.

    There are too many complexities to these issues so I understand why people choose to engage in hivemind like behavior online. I am not even that much pro-capitalism, and I am definitely not against diversity or inclusion. Saying you don’t trust DEI as a concept (because we already have anti-discrimination laws here) or the people implementing DEI doesn’t mean you’re against diversity or inclusion.

    • ZeroHora@lemmy.ml
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      2
      ·
      11 hours ago

      There’s no such thing as imperialism in the modern world. The fact that some countries insist on blaming their shortcomings on imperialism is a distraction tactic so their citizens don’t turn on their failing or corrupt governments.

      This dude is baiting, there’s limits to stupidity.

    • Cowbee [he/they]@lemmy.ml
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      8
      ·
      edit-2
      20 hours ago

      Honestly, if I were more conspiratorially minded, I’d say you were a Marxist trying deliberately to feed free rhetorical wins and make liberalism look bad. Like, genuinely, you go around provoking Marxists then complain about a mysterious “downvote brigade.” If you play online games, you’re “feeding.”

      Your point about being anti-immigration was specifically about nationalist conceptions of “cultural erosion” and a “shift in values.” This is pure xenophobia, plain and simple. There isn’t anything to address here, this is what conservatives say all the time. You called these immigrants “dangerous to democracy” due to having “cultural differences.” It’s painfully clear in its xenophobia.

      Second, Imperialism. It is a fact that over time, corporations monopolize and spread internationally, to seek further markets, and in doing so export industrial Capital as a way to pay cheaper labor costs and expropriate super-profits. This process results in intentional under-development of countries to keep them in line, including performing coups and regime change to keep the wheels turning. The US has done this all over the world, especially in Latin America and the Middle East. You can listen to Blowback if you want to hear the evil ways the US has slaughtered and invaded for profit, or read Michael Hudson’s Super-Imperialism if you prefer books. Blaming, say, the Iraqis for the US murdering 1 million of them is monstrous behavior.

      The idea that Marxism is being pushed by foreign countries to destabilize western democracies is laughable. Marxism has been demonized throughout the West for centuries, this conspiracy doesn’t exist. Further, every time you make the claim that Marxism is a “failed ideology,” you’re shown the huge successes of AES states like the former USSR with doubling life expectancies, providing free and high quality healthcare and education, over tripling literacy rates to 99.9%, going from a largely feudal backwater to space in half a century, ending famine, and more, or the PRC’s modern successes and poverty eradication. You don’t actually have any counters, and every time you get proven wrong you help create more Marxists.

      You circle back to the anti-DEI dogwhistle, believing programs for diversity are foreign Marxist ploys to destroy the economy and democracy. This is conspiracy theory nonsense that conservatives love to spout, your positions are fundamentally identical with them.

    • AntiOutsideAktion@lemmy.ml
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      6
      ·
      20 hours ago

      why does anyone believe they have the right to be anywhere?

      Isn’t this the guy who was talking about authoritarianism earlier?